James Manyika from Google: AI Will Not Destroy Jobs
Optimism in the Face of Automation: A Nuanced View of AI and Employment
Aaron Levie, CEO of Box, recently presented an interesting argument: jobs are more complex to automate than AI companies suggest. According to Levie, the human aspects of work, such as judgment and context, will not be replaced anytime soon. This perspective invites optimism about the future of employment.
That optimism can be set against the views of James Manyika, Senior Vice President at Google and Alphabet. Manyika leads Google's research operations and labs, as well as a team dedicated to studying the societal impacts of technologies, including AI. His role involves assessing the consequences of AI systems like Gemini and shaping Google's strategy accordingly.
It is crucial to note that seven out of ten Americans now oppose the construction of data centers in their communities. The message conveyed by the tech industry, suggesting that AI might first replace jobs before threatening humanity, has failed to convince the public. In this context, Manyika adopts a more optimistic approach. He believes that jobs are harder to automate than Silicon Valley claims, and that the process will be slower than the most pessimistic forecasts. This opinion is shared by some of his colleagues at Google, such as Demis Hassabis, CEO of DeepMind, who recently warned against the replacement of software developers by AI tools.
Unlike many tech leaders, Manyika has formed his opinions over a career outside Silicon Valley. A former executive at McKinsey, he co-authored a report on the potential effects of automation on employment nearly a decade ago. He also co-chaired the UN Secretary-General's High-Level Advisory Group on AI and served as Vice Chair of the National AI Advisory Committee under President Biden.
In the face of alarmist predictions from some competing companies, like Microsoft and Anthropic, which foresee a massive disappearance of white-collar jobs, Manyika remains skeptical. "Some of these predictions were made two years ago, claiming that 50% of jobs would be eliminated," he explains. "Two years have passed, and those predictions have not come true."
Highlights of His Analysis
James Manyika earned his PhD in AI and robotics at Oxford, decades before AI became the biggest news topic in the world. Yet his interest goes back even further. He did his undergraduate degree at the University of Zimbabwe, and his undergraduate thesis was the first paper he ever published. It was already about AI: training and modeling an artificial neural network. A visiting postdoc from Canada, who had worked with Geoff Hinton's team in Montreal-Toronto, had suggested he build a neural network for that thesis. It was the very first thing he published, in 1993.
Two things captured his interest, he recounts. He grew up with Star Trek and watched 2001: A Space Odyssey, so the idea of AI fascinated him. He was also intrigued by the idea that it would be possible to build systems capable of performing advanced cognitive tasks. It was to keep exploring that path that he pursued a PhD in AI and robotics at Oxford.
Manyika has since spent a good part of his career trying to measure how technologies change economies. He spent a long time at McKinsey, where, nearly a decade ago, he wrote a paper titled "Jobs Lost, Jobs Gained". He is now at Google, where he can see what happens when these tools actually land in the workplace. In the current debate about the future of AI and jobs, he describes this as "such an exciting moment": technology and its capabilities are expanding at an incredible pace. But when it comes to translating that into effects on work and jobs, he says he has "a very mixed view." It is pretty much what that paper said ten years ago, which he still considers correct: there will be jobs that decline, there will be jobs that grow, and most importantly, as a third aspect, many more jobs will change.
Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir
Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.
Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.
Choisissez votre rythme
Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic
Whether one looks at the global economy, at the sector level, or at each profession, the mix of these three things differs. But all three will happen. Research has not changed much on this point, in his view. The debate is about the mix of these three things, rather than about whether they will happen.
Manyika is now employed by one of the biggest beneficiaries of the current wave of AI, which raises the question of how to distinguish the labor economist from the Senior Vice President at Google. He says he hears both. Less than the Senior Vice President at Google, it is the AI researcher and computer scientist in him who is "extraordinarily excited" about the pace of technology. That part of him thinks this is going to be extraordinary, and that it is going to happen very, very quickly.
The labor economist in him tempers that view: these things do not unfold as quickly in the economy, and the dynamics are more mixed. He therefore says he hears "almost two speeds." He often thinks that the community of AI researchers, to which he belongs, tends to exaggerate what is happening in labor markets based on what it sees at the technological frontiers. "These are two very different conversations," he sums up.
At the McKinsey Global Institute, Manyika had found that about 50% of tasks could be automated through AI, but that only about 10% of professions would be fully automatable. A few generations of AI later, all the elements have evolved, he says. At the task level, many more tasks are now possible to automate, and that picture has evolved quite rapidly. But if one looks at the composition of professions (the Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks somewhere between 850 and 1000 actual professions) and asks how many existing professions have the majority, say 90%, of their constituent tasks automatable, that number is still below 10%. Most researchers would still say that, he maintains.
Many tasks seem difficult to automate, partly because AI cannot yet perform them, partly because of coupled tasks, where the weak link slows down the combination. If two tasks are taken and one of them can be automated, but they need to be performed together, things will only go as fast as the weakest link. Most jobs have these couplings, which make complete automation very difficult.
Another change noted by Manyika is the duration of tasks. In 2017, among the tasks possible to automate, some were very short: 30 seconds or a minute was about the maximum duration for which the automated performance of a task could be reliably predicted. Today, some of these tasks can be performed for over four hours. The duration of tasks with reasonably predictable completion has made huge strides.
The result is a gap. The share of automatable tasks is now trending much higher than 50%, while the number of jobs that could be fully automated remains stubbornly in the same place as it was ten years ago. Manyika attributes this in part to a fuller understanding of entire jobs: they have a much more complex mix of tasks, and this idea of weak links or coupled tasks is very important in most professions. Across the entire economy, most complex tasks cannot be automated. The entire jobs that can be automated to more than 90% therefore remain relatively few.
Most of the debate among labor economists, he continues, is whether, in the next decade, that number is more like 2 or 3% or more like 9 or 10%. He does not think anyone who has looked at the automation of entire jobs would say it is 50% or one of those extraordinarily high numbers.
That is why he comes back to the idea that three things will happen. Yes, there will be job declines. But there will also be jobs that grow: existing jobs that increase in demand, because technology often changes the landscape of demand, and new jobs that are created. Manyika points out that David Autor and others have shown that, going back to 1945 and comparing it to today, more than 60% of the jobs in the current economy did not exist back then, and that many were introduced as a result of technological changes that created the category.
"But the most important effect is that the very nature of work is changing," he concludes.
Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français
L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.