AI in UX: Promise of Efficiency or Risk to Quality?
AI Raises Growing Concerns
Artificial intelligence (AI) is at the heart of current debates, and a 2025 Pew Research study reveals that 50% of Americans express more concern than enthusiasm about its increasing use in daily life. This worry is shared by both experts and non-experts, who express a common desire to exert more control over this technology. However, these figures would likely vary if the focus were solely on workers in the tech sector.
Being skeptical of AI may seem paradoxical at the head of a UX research team, but this position is not an isolated one. This skepticism does not mean opposition to all AI tools. Some can be extremely useful when used in the right context and with the right limitations. However, a measured and thoughtful approach to their use is preferable.
AI in the UX Sector: Between Promise and Reality
In the field of user experience (UX), AI is often seen as a revolution capable of transforming design and research processes. It promises increased efficiency, allowing product managers to quickly create mockups and designers to move directly from prototype to code. Yet, the idea that AI can replace the quality of research is misleading. AI-generated prototypes, while functional, often require revisions by engineers, and the insights produced can sometimes lead companies in the wrong direction. Thus, AI does not so much change the design process as it adds additional revision steps.
A Measured Approach to AI in UX
In a team of eight UX researchers, including a manager and UX operations, a thoughtful approach was adopted to integrate AI. While the adoption of AI has been slower than in other companies, the team compensates for this lag with marked enthusiasm. Teams, including those in UX, are encouraged to proactively identify opportunities to integrate AI into their workflows to enhance efficiency. Management, at all levels, is committed to this initiative, although discussions about risks are rare.
Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir
Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.
Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.
Choisissez votre rythme
Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic
The push to incorporate AI into all team workflows is strong, often without a thorough consideration of the risks and trade-offs. This pressure to adopt AI quickly is common in the tech sector, but it must be balanced with critical reflection on long-term implications.
Guidelines for Reasoned Use of AI
To guide the team, a "north star" was defined: AI should support, not replace, the quality of research. Key skills have been identified, and guidelines have been established to preserve these skills. For example, AI should not be used to develop research questions, but it can be used to clean survey data or prepare data for analysis. Sections of research documents generated by AI must be clearly labeled.
Cultivating and developing essential professional skills, such as good qualitative interviewing techniques, rigorous data analysis, and persuasive storytelling, remains a priority. The aim is to maintain an environment where researchers, at all stages of their careers, can learn and practice these skills.
Evaluating AI Tools
The implementation of AI is approached with a "risk versus reward" mindset, asking questions about the effectiveness, time savings, and cost-effectiveness of the tools used. Often, the answers highlight that AI does not always meet expectations, but these discussions help refocus the debate on the added value for the company. What works and what does not is regularly documented for each tool, and their usage is tracked.
The Importance of Critical Reflection
The point is not to oppose new technologies, but to maintain critical reflection in adopting AI. The risk is that AI may harm the ability to think for oneself and that, in the quest for speed, the time needed to produce quality results may be lost. Ultimately, the goal remains to support the team in their work, and AI must be integrated in a way that does not compromise this objective. The adoption of new technologies must be accompanied by reflection on the risks involved, so as not to hinder the ability to think independently and produce quality outcomes.
Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français
L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.