Black Friday: AI Agents Join Holiday Shopping

Public AI agents are approaching their first holiday shopping season, with Muse and Instinct among the tools likely to be utilized. Their use for purchasing is estimated to remain around 1% of online shoppers. Access to retailers, as well as consumer trust, remain limitations to delegation.
Amazon Blocks Robots, Walmart Welcomes Them
Amazon blocks external agents and prioritizes Alexa for its customers. Walmart takes the opposite approach: the retailer is deploying tools that facilitate purchases made by these assistants. At Kantar, retail analyst Gina Logan warns that a poor experience could undermine trust built by retailers over years, if not decades.
Other retailers have yet to decide their stance towards third-party agents. Michael Fiddelke, CEO of Target, along with the head of online experiences at Home Depot, state that they are focusing their AI strategies on customer experience. Logan compares the current hesitations to the initial reluctance towards shopping carts: their adoption, she recalls, was encouraged by people tasked with demonstrating their use.
Uber Records About 500 Transactions via Agents
At Uber, approximately 500 transactions came from agents during the last week of October, out of about 320 million, according to the company. Both Uber and DoorDash report that these tools are used by very few customers. Bain & Co., based on Similarweb data reviewed this week, estimates the contribution of AI assistants to be less than 1% of web traffic for retailers.
However, progress is rapid. According to Bain, a search conducted with AI is nearly twice as effective as a traditional web search in leading to a sale. Abhishek Bora, head of growth at streetwear retailer All Star Elite, attributes about 1% of his site’s traffic to agents, primarily Muse. He reports one purchase through this intermediary every week or every two weeks, without being able to clearly distinguish transactions executed by the bot from items identified and then purchased by the customer.
According to Zappi, 1% of respondents spontaneously mention AI among their means of shopping. Steve Phillips, founder and director of innovation at this consumer analytics platform, describes users as generally younger, wealthier, and more tech-savvy. He compares them to the early customers of Apple phones.
Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir
Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.
Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.
Choisissez votre rythme
Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic
Joko Prioritizes Product Discovery
For Xavier Starkloff, co-founder and CEO of the AI shopping platform Joko, the current priority is to better facilitate product discovery rather than completing transactions. He believes agents extend the uses of chatbots and assistants by mobilizing more sources, interactions, and time. He finds this capability particularly relevant for finding promotions during Black Friday. All Star Elite has, for its part, added machine-readable data to its site to help agents navigate its catalog and understand its offerings.
Gina Logan believes this Black Friday could give AI a significant role, albeit without complete autonomy. She states that two-thirds of shoppers use it at least occasionally, but more than half want to retain control over their decisions. Phillips also cites a trust barrier: he compares the situation to the early days of hotel searches online, when travelers would spot a room online before calling to book.
Muse Suggests Knives to Dean Mandelos
Dean Mandelos, a 29-year-old therapist from New York, asked Muse to find a Christmas gift for his sister, who loves to cook. Launched by Meta in September, the agent had already helped him post ads and sell items on eBay, and then gather and sort quotes to replace a door. For his sister, Muse suggested knives.
Mandelos acknowledges the usefulness of the ideas but criticizes them for lacking social sensitivity: he would have preferred a cookbook over equipment. He also reports outdated listings, items that have already been sold, and blocked access on Amazon as well as eBay. While he wishes to let the agent choose more, he feels he does not yet have enough reasons to trust it.
Agents Sought for Christmas Gifts
Bhasin plans to use her agents this year to find gifts from specific retailers, both online and in-store, especially when she can find multiple presents there. Mandelos believes that a gift chosen with AI might seem thoughtless, but he also thinks that obtaining a truly unique suggestion will likely require many instructions, another possible way to express affection. He is experimenting with searches for his friends, accompanied by detailed instructions and a strict budget. For his sister, he continues his search without delegating to the agent.
Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français
L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.