Brief IA
›

OpenAI Modifies Business Hub Legal Terms

Use Cases·Tom Levy·

OpenAI Modifies Business Hub Legal Terms

OpenAI Modifies Business Hub Legal Terms
Key Takeaways
1OpenAI confirmed the change in the Business Hub terms on November 18.
2According to Gary Kibel, the waivers no longer pertain to disputes unrelated to the use of the service.
3A specialized lawyer believes that claims for damages are still possible.
Why it matters : According to Gary Kibel, the new clauses still restrict certain remedies related to the service, but no longer cover disputes unrelated to it.

OpenAI revised the terms of the ChatGPT Business Hub on November 18, just days after its launch and following alerts from lawyers regarding companies' recourse options. According to the legal experts consulted, the new version reduces the scope of waivers without eliminating all restrictions.

Companies Retain Some Recourse Against OpenAI

Access to the courts remains partially restricted, according to an intellectual property and technology lawyer who spoke anonymously. He believes that companies waive their right to seek an injunction preventing OpenAI from using certain customer data. However, a claim for damages would still be possible, even though this process presents practical difficulties.

Gary Kibel, a partner at Davis+ Gilbert and advisor to media and advertising clients, now distinguishes disputes related to the service from other types of conflicts. According to him, certain claims related to the Business Hub or its AI sales agents are still subject to a waiver, but disputes unrelated to these uses are no longer affected. These agents are primarily company-specific chatbots.

OpenAI states that it has replaced the standalone provision regarding covered claims with wording in section 5.2. The company explains that the waiver now pertains to claims arising from the sales agent, particularly those concerning the use of customer data with it.

Service Statistics and Risks of Initial Clauses

Available since the previous week, the Business Hub provides verified accounts with direct metrics on the presence of their sites in ChatGPT. They can track mentions, profile views, clicks, and the topics that led to their discovery. Publishers had previously relied heavily on estimates to assess this activity.

However, accepting the initial terms could have implications beyond access to statistics, according to the lawyers consulted. They believed that section 10 could impose the abandonment of certain claims against OpenAI, including for content published before registration. For publishers seeking to protect their publications and generate revenue, future actions based on copyright could thus have been limited.

La lettre du soirGratuit · 19 h

Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir

Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.

Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.

Choisissez votre rythme

Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic

Alan Chapell, a privacy expert and founder of Chapell and Associates, notably pointed out an arbitration obligation coupled with a waiver of class action procedures. According to him, companies risked having to settle their disputes separately outside of court, including for certain claims predating the agreement. They had 30 days to opt out of arbitration; failing to do so could restrict their access to evidence, their appeal options, and their ability to establish a public judicial precedent.

OpenAI and Lawyers Diverge on Initial Clauses

An industry executive, who remained anonymous, claims to have advised the legal teams of publishers to exercise caution after the terms were published on November 10. The modification then occurred after lawyers' concerns were made public, just hours after an initial media inquiry was directed to OpenAI.

The company's spokesperson confirmed the update on November 18 and stated that the previous wording was not intended to apply to the situation raised. He also indicated that OpenAI continuously reviews its wording to make it clearer.

Several lawyers, on the other hand, believe that the initial wording likely stemmed from a deliberate choice. Gary Kibel dismisses the notion of negligence: he believes that OpenAI was intentionally seeking to obtain a waiver of all relevant claims and considers the approach aggressive.

Meta Also Faced Opposition from Publishers

A few weeks earlier, Meta had faced a backlash against its new business terms, which would have allowed the extraction of sites from account holders. Publishers, professional organizations, government officials, and regulators mobilized worldwide. In response, Meta announced it would suspend the rollout to explain the changes to partners and key stakeholders.

The exploitation of publications also fuels tensions between publishers and AI companies. Court documents were made public two months ago in the lawsuit between the New York Times and OpenAI and Microsoft.

Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français

L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.