Brief IA
›

Qwen Code: Only 0.8% of "Google" Lines Are Actually from Google

Research·Tom Levy·

Qwen Code: Only 0.8% of "Google" Lines Are Actually from Google

Qwen Code: Only 0.8% of "Google" Lines Are Actually from Google
Key Takeaways
11,110 Qwen Code files carry a "Copyright Google LLC" header.
258 files (5.2%) are identical byte-for-byte to Google blobs; 0.8% of lines marked "Google" correspond to Google code.
3The files from the "mem0" connector are not found upstream despite their labeling.
Why it matters : The audit recommends verifying provenance at the byte level rather than relying on headers, which are considered unreliable.

A byte-by-byte audit of the Qwen Code repository reveals a significant discrepancy between the labeling "Copyright Google LLC" and the reality of the code. Out of 1,110 files displaying this header, only 58 exactly match Google blobs, representing 5.2%, and just 0.8% of the lines under the "Google" header actually come from Google. The method relies on the history of Google Gemini CLI, weighs the results by lines, and includes a reverse check.

Very few overlaps despite 1,110 "Google" headers

Out of the 1,110 Qwen Code files bearing the "Copyright Google LLC" header, only 58 are identical byte-for-byte to files present in the studied period on Google's side, which is 5.2%. When weighted by the number of lines, only 0.8% of the lines under these headers actually correspond to bytes sourced from Google. Furthermore, the files from the "mem0" connector are found nowhere upstream, even though they carry the "Google" label.

Le brief IA que lisent les pros

Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir

Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.

Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.

Choisissez votre rythme

Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic

Verification through git blobs and reverse control

The audit began by organizing the headers of each TypeScript file, then examined whether the byte sequences of these files were present in the commit history of Google Gemini CLI, using git blobs. This approach aimed to limit errors related to changes that occurred after a fork, as well as modifications of names or locations. The classification of cases distinguished strictly identical copies at the byte level, those modified but retaining the same location, those moved or altered, and those never present upstream. The results were weighted by the number of lines, and a reverse check ensured that no Google code was hidden under Qwen headers.

Context and scope: headers treated as boilerplate

Qwen Code stopped using Google 10 months ago. The audit concludes that copyright headers primarily serve as persistent boilerplate, without guaranteeing the actual provenance of the code. Review tools and processes mandate the presence of this block, but do not ensure its update or verification against the actual author. It is therefore recommended to conduct byte-level checks on any derived code before relying on the attribution indicated by the headers.

Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français

L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.