SAP Ties Joule 2.0 On-Premises to Cloud Commitment

SAP announced in May of this year access to Joule 2.0 for on-premise customers accepting a cloud transition with RISE with SAP. The DSAG contests the commercial terms, which it deems unsuitable for many small businesses equipped with a single ERP.
SAP Migrations Face Ongoing Resistance
By Q4 2024, only 39% of the 35,000 ECC customers worldwide had acquired or subscribed to SAP S/4HANA licenses, according to Gartner. SAP was also lagging nearly 2 billion euros behind its target for phasing out on-premise support. The lengthy and complex transfers are met with persistent resistance.
SAP's ERPs are used by thousands of customers, including very large enterprises. The vendor is seeking to lead them towards S/4HANA and the cloud, where it has promised to capture a larger share of their spending. Organizations retaining old ERPs are also under pressure to adopt AI-driven automation.
Thomas Henzler, who became president of the DSAG, the SAP user association for Germany, Switzerland, and Austria last month, highlights the gap between their situation and the autonomous enterprise envisioned by SAP. According to him, many are still preparing for their transition to S/4HANA. He reports their concerns about the necessary steps to access AI and the implications for their cloud strategy.
DSAG Challenges Conditions Imposed on SMEs
For Thomas Henzler, who nonetheless praises the progress represented by Joule Studio 2.0, the main blockage in connecting ECC and legacy on-premise systems to Joule lies in the commercial terms. He describes a significant commitment to RISE, accompanied by a minimum ratio between cloud maintenance and on-premise maintenance. The DSAG continues its discussions with the vendor regarding these conditions.
Le brief IA que les pros lisent chaque soir
Les 7 actus IA du jour, décryptées en 5 min. Gratuit.
Inclus dès l'inscription : notre sélection des meilleurs guides & comparatifs IA.
Choisissez votre rythme
Gratuit · Pas de spam · Désabonnement en 1 clic
According to its president, a company with a single ECC installation must transform all of its on-premise maintenance into a cloud subscription to meet this threshold. He sees this as a contradiction with the expected utility of the on-premise connector and warns that these requirements could deprive many customers of the latest AI tools. He considers the arrangement irrelevant for most SMEs.
In his view, this model is only suitable for large accounts with multiple SAP ERPs: they can transfer their installations successively and unlock AI for those that remain. He asserts that access to AI requires initiating a migration to RISE.
SAP Distinguishes Between Commercial Commitment and Technical Transfer
SAP defends a distinction between the contractual commitment to its cloud ERP and the actual date of system transfer. According to a company spokesperson, customers meeting the technical and commercial criteria can utilize compatible AI functions on their ECC or SAP S/4HANA installations during their modernization. The announced access involves a modification of support agreements and commercial terms while migrations are still underway.
This possibility shifts the policy outlined to investors in July 2023 by Christian Klein, CEO of SAP. At that time, he reserved the new capabilities for the cloud, whether public or private, within RISE, excluding both on-premise installations and hosting with a hyperscaler outside of this program. RISE was launched in early 2021 with partners and cloud providers.
Joule Studio 2.0 is the enhanced platform designed to create and deploy AI agents tasked with automating business processes.
Brief IA — L'actualité IA en français
L'essentiel de l'actualité de l'intelligence artificielle, décrypté et expliqué chaque jour.